Viewing from Anothers Perspective Sets Humans Apart?


Recently I discussed what sets humans apart from other animals and species. The basic question, which has been kicked around for centuries is what makes man so unique? So, different than the other species we see? Many immediately take their religious doctrine and use it to answer the question; they say things like "God made us in his image." The animals were put here for us to use, eat, fish and etc; they are indeed here to serve man? After kicking around such notions which cannot be proved either way; a gentleman, David, came up with an interesting concept.

Of course he too borrowed the concept from his readings and learnings and made it part of his belief system. Here is how it goes; "empathy is what sets us apart" basically that is it. Here is David's longer version:

"Empathy: If anything, the ability to see from another's perspective is what sets humans apart from the rest of the animals. It is the basis of many of the qualities that we hold in highest regard: kindness, charity, mercy, welfare, forgiveness. Far from being irrational, empathy confers a distinct advantage in any social situation. It provides a foundation for promises, contracts, and deals. To a large extent it is the glue that binds society."

I completely had to reject this and although I was polite; obviously not wanting any coffee spilled on my face here is why and where I differ and my basis for such. Although you might be able to give other examples such as a dog going over to a child who fell off his skateboard and licking his face or some such event you observed. I have a more compelling argument against David's notion: Actually chimpanzees that have been taught sign language have empathy too and from the other human's perspective. In fact this has been well documented by a Washington State research facility. A woman who was pregnant came to work everyday with the Chimps. Then one day she was missing for about a week, she had miss carried and then her stomach was small again, the Chimp asked what happened in sign language and where is the baby? The woman told her back, "it died" the chimp started to cry and hug that lady and said it was "sooo sorry' in sign language?

So in fact empathy is not only a human trait, David will need to try again. As matter of fact, I am still unconvinced for sure humans are that special in anything really. And on further study of other known earth species, I cannot come up with one single difference that sets humans apart. Think on this; let me know if you come up with something.

"Lance Winslow" - If you have innovative thoughts and unique perspectives, come think with Lance; www.WorldThinkTank.net/wttbbs







Related News



Gaston urges a change in Jays' hitting philosophy - National Post

Canada.com

Gaston urges a change in Jays' hitting philosophy
National Post, Canada -17 hours ago
But he insisted that if the Jays collectively convert to his hitting philosophy, the team can still fashion a successful season. "I'm hoping 10 games above ...
Bats starting to show lifeToronto Star
Gaston working with Jays' hittersMLB.com
Marcum returns to find not much has changed for JaysCBC.ca
all 641 news articles

Two candidates named for East Jordan superintendent - Deseret News

Two candidates named for East Jordan superintendent
Deseret News, UT -6 hours ago
He received his doctorate of philosophy and juris doctorate from Brigham Young University. Doty is assistant commissioner and director of policy studies ...


Pass-first philosophy comes up short - The Gazette (Montreal)

Pass-first philosophy comes up short
The Gazette (Montreal), Canada -Jul 21, 2008
Trestman isn't likely to change his pass-first philosophy anytime soon. The long-time NFL offensive co-ordinator has boasted teams that have produced ...

Soapbox Philosophy: Imagine George Carlin leading VBS - West Branch Times

Soapbox Philosophy: Imagine George Carlin leading VBS
West Branch Times, IA -9 hours ago
by Gregory R. Norfleet · Op-Ed · July 23, 2008 The late George Carlin is not the type of guy who would show up to help at Vacation Bible School, ...

Philosophy vs. Reality - Intellectual Conservative

Philosophy vs. Reality
Intellectual Conservative, AZ -12 hours ago
by Phillip Ellis Jackson How people embracing a philosophy act is more important in evaluating the wisdom and utility of that philosophy than studying all ...

Briles: Baylor can't be scared of success - Dallas Morning News

Briles: Baylor can't be scared of success
Dallas Morning News, TX -6 hours ago
I understand your philosophy there about changing the image and getting some respect for Baylor. What's your biggest challenge in that regard? ...

Frederick, Md., Architecture Firm Injects 'Green' Philosophy into ... - istockAnalyst.com

Frederick, Md., Architecture Firm Injects 'Green' Philosophy into ...
istockAnalyst.com, OR -2 hours ago
By Ike Wilson, The Frederick News-Post, Md. Jul. 23--Employees eat peppers, tomatoes, lettuce and cucumbers out of a blossoming garden at Zavos ...

Dr. Keri Chiappino Adopts Defeat Autism Now!® Philosophy - NewsLI

Dr. Keri Chiappino Adopts Defeat Autism Now!® Philosophy
NewsLI, NY -3 hours ago
The Defeat Autism Now! philosophy and the field of Chiropractic Neurology share core beliefs, most importantly the need to address the underlying causes of ...

Want to get ahead? Take philosophy - Telegraph-Journal

Want to get ahead? Take philosophy
Telegraph-Journal, Canada -14 hours ago
SAINT JOHN - Philosophy has become more, not less, relevant in today's world, and the enrolment numbers are there to prove it. Since 2002, UNB Saint John ...

McCain swings toward low tax philosophy - Financial Times

Boston Globe

McCain swings toward low tax philosophy
Financial Times, UK -Jul 17, 2008
The apparent shift marks a victory for the conservative philosophy of supply-side economics championed by Mr Kemp over Mr Gramm, who is considered a deficit ...
Gramm: In or out?MSNBC
McCain Owes Us More Than Gramm's ResignationYahoo! News
Phil Gramm meant what he saidSeattle Post Intelligencer
Augusta Chronicle - The Wichita Eagle
all 837 news articles